Bear McCreary: Battlestar Galactica Season 3 (Score)
Wednesday, April 30th, 2008
Have I mentioned I love BSG?
I don’t think there’s a whole lot that I can say about season 3’s score that I haven’t said about season 2’s. It’s good music, solid orchestration, blah, blah, blah.
Oh. Wait. This was Season 3. This had the greatest cover song/musical reveal I’ve seen in years.
All Along the Watchtower.
That’s right. In the alternate universe that contains the Battlestar Galactica and all the survivors of the 12 Colonies, someone managed to write the same song Bob Dylan did.
Of course, in our world, Jimi Hendrix took and it made it even better.
In theirs, it just turned on four of the final five Cylons. Not a big difference, sure, but still.
My excitement over the release of the score was almost exclusively wrapped around getting Watchtower in a listenable format. But after listening to the album, as a whole, I found I was ever so slightly disappointed.
When Bear McCreary did things right in the season 3 score, he did them very right. Of course, the converse feels very true, too.
The first 5 tracks, Violence and Variations, The Dance, Battlestar Sonatica, Dirty Hands, and Heeding the Call all do it very right. They convey, better than most, the tone, the energy (or lack there of), and a bit of the scene.
Under the Wing, Kat’s Sacrifice, Someone to Trust, and Deathbed And Maelstrom all feel like they fall flat. Maybe it’s just that they can’t manage the visual as well, and this makes them weaker in my mind. In any event, these are often missed when listening to the score because they get mentally passed by. Mean, I know, but it’s what happens.
In the end: Bear’s score did exactly what Season 3 did, when it got it right, it got it very right. The rest of the time, it felt lacking. This may just as well be the fault of the story writers. In any event, all the things done wrong on this score are strongly obscured by the many, many things done quite right.
Album of the year? So far, it is my book.